EngagePerspectivesLiving in and with Paradox
Wellness Icon

Living in and with Paradox

One of the most interesting things about thinking and communicating is the ability to hold two contradictory thoughts at once. Plato exemplified what it is to hold a paradox when he said, “he knows one thing and that is that he knows nothing.”[1] It makes sense even though the reasoning is contradictory. We, as readers, make the meaning, filling in and explaining the things that do not make sense. In a similar way, contronyms are words that mean both their meaning and their opposite. Words like “sanction” which means both to “give approval” and to “impose a penalty on” depend deeply on context.[2] Our brains do not rebel but accept these paradoxes of meaning held within the same word or contradictory ideas in the same quote.

photo of the Lou Ruvo Center for Brain Health

I am the wisest man alive, for I know one thing, and that is that I know nothing.

— Plato, The Republic

Making Meaning in Confusing Times

Paradoxes and contronyms seem especially important in the present moment.  Many things seem contextually confusing.  Information is different and misleading and often contradictory.

One particular paradox is gripping me at present.  As the holidays approach, how do I accept family members, whose ideas manifested by their vote in the 2020 election, represent ideas that I do not accept at all. Before 2016, this was not much of an issue for me.  Even though I am a political scientist, with previous elections it was not difficult at all to shrug off voting differences because the stakes were much lower.

This year, I know that as I see certain family members I will be flooded by contradictory emotions, love and anger; elation to see them and deep sadness at seeing them and being reminded of who they supported.  Perhaps what works best here is to cling to the meaning found in paradoxes like Plato’s quote above.

Plato’s Paradox and My Own

Here is what I read into Plato’s quote above: even though experience has taught him that his knowledge is always incomplete (that he knows nothing), that does not stop him from trying to know.  He is not finished with knowing even in his knowledge that what he knows will never be the full picture. He keeps learning and knowing and working towards filling in the whole picture.  For Plato, knowing more is the greater value, the one by which he derives his context and his meaning.

This helps me as I think about Thanksgiving (even if it turns out to be over zoom) when I see those whom I love who voted differently than I did, whose ideas I may never fully understand.  Even though I know I will never accept their ideas, I will not stop trying to love and accept them.  I will not close myself off from listening to them and letting them know why their beliefs and specifically what about their beliefs do not make sense to me.  I will not stop because loving my family is the value by which I choose to derive context and meaning.

Our country needs to heal.  Even in this paradoxical moment.  We need to make meaning out of a context of love.  And though I am motivated in this direction, I am not exactly sure what this will look like in practice.  I will start by listening well and see what happens.

[1]https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/tag/paradox
[2]https://getpocket.com/explore/item/25-words-that-are-their-own-opposites?utm_source=pocket-newtab

Related Content

Keep Reading

Community Care
Podcast

Self Care, Community Care, and Social Change: Youth Access to Nutritious Food

Jarrett Stein, a two-time Penn alumnus and a staff member at the Netter Center for Community Partnerships, joins host Dr. Lia Howard to discuss food awareness and education.Learn More
The Schuylkill River looking north towards the Philadelphia skyline.
Blog

“Nature Rx” field trip to Awbury Arboretum

As part of the “Nature Rx” course, the students and I have taken some trips to local gardens and arboretums. On October 25, we visited… Learn More
Students at the University Community Engagement: A Dialogue Amongst Penn Students Involved in Community Work event.
Event Recap

University Community Engagement: A Dialogue Amongst Penn Students Involved in Community Work Recap

Utilizing the SNF Paideia Small Grant Program, I hosted the event “University Community Engagement: A Dialogue Amongst Penn Students… Learn More