EngagePerspectivesVeteran Police Chiefs Insist Metropolitan Forces can be Improved and Reformed
Dialogue Icon

Veteran Police Chiefs Insist Metropolitan Forces can be Improved and Reformed

At a Red and Blue Exchange event in December, two veteran police chiefs insisted that metropolitan forces can be improved and reformed, but it will take changes in law, union contracts, recruitment, training and policy.

Police Commissioner Charles Ramsey on computer screen talking during event on police reform

Charles Ramsey, former head of the Washington, D.C., and Philadelphia police forces, joined with Michael Harrison, current commissioner in Baltimore, to discuss police reform with interviewer Dave Davies of NPR’s Fresh Air in a Zoom event.

(Ramsey was the voice that CNN turned to during the chaos at the U.S. Capitol to explain what Capitol Police had done wrong and what could be done to get the situation under control.)

Harrison, who also led the New Orleans police, said one of the keys is training police officers how to intervene in situations where a fellow officer has lost self-control and is about to harm a civilian or violate their rights.  He said officers have to grasp that this protects not just the civilian, but the fellow officer, who is in danger of ruining his career.

Ramsey, who co-led a task force on police reform set up by President Obama, agreed with Harrison and said another needed change is in contract and arbitration rules that make it hard for department leaders to discipline or remove problematic officers.

Both men said they had had no negative experiences with police growing up, but said they understand why some African-Americans are so exhausted and angry about how their communities are treated by many police officers.  Dismantling the police, they said, is not the answer because it would leave communities of color even more besieged by violent criminals.

They did say they support the idea of shifting some resources into behavioral health services and more collaborative approaches, but cautioned that this is a complicated endeavor to pull off, akin, in Harrison’s analogy, to a sport team continuing to play games while building a new stadium.  You can’t, he observed, simply demolish the old stadium before you have an interim solution in place.

This was the Red and Blue Exchange’s first speaker event of the academic year. Coming events will feature a panel on the future of conservatism in late February and an evening with social psychologist Jonathan Haidt on March 18.

The conversation with former Philadelphia and D.C. Metro Commissioner Charles Ramsey and Baltimore Commissioner Michael Harrison is co-sponsored by the Quattrone Center of the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School and the Red and Blue Exchange, an initiative of Penn’s SNF Paideia Program.

This police reform program is made possible by the generosity of the Gamba Family.

Quattrone center logo

Keep Reading

Friends sitting next to lake watching sunset

How Perceptions of Support Network Impacts Emotional, Physical and Social Wellbeing of College Students

In this special episode of the The PARK Podcast, Steven-John Kounoupis and Venus Tian of the Icarus Research Group weave together academic research and first-account interviews to deliver a multi-dimensional conversation on social isolation and mental health. The discussion focuses on the nature of social isolation and social networks in college, sharing diverse perspective on how socialization impacts health and how social wellness impacts our ability to have strong connections with others. Learn More
Photograph of old house

Contemplative Social Movements and How We See

The desire to change society resonates well with Gen Z for whom political activism is a generational hallmark. John Della Volpe’s book, Fight: How Gen Z is Channeling their Fear and Passion to Save America, uses survey data to demonstrate how Gen Z is using democratic means to voice their frustrations with older generations’ inaction on pressing social issues. “For them, America at times has resembled a dystopia. But they won’t sit back and take it. They’ve decided to fight their own war against injustice and inequality right here at home.” From climate change, to gun control, racial equality to reproductive rights, Gen Z is speaking out and showing up to contentious political battles. Learn More
book cover

A Book Club Where You Don't have to Read the Book to Feel Included in the Conversation

Nineteenth surgeon general of the United States Dr. Vivek H. Murthy, traveled the nation to contextualize loneliness. He listened to voices often unheard, met with change-makers, and started a wellness group with friends. His findings toward a connected life served as a starting point toward a conversation on empathy in this year's SNF Paideia fellows’ book club.Learn More